Thursday, March 12, 2020

Bombay as seen through the eyes of St Gregorios of Parumala.


The month of March this year marks the 125th anniversary of the visit of the entourage of the saintly fathers led by St Gregorios of Parumala (Parumala Thirumeni), who on their way to the Holy Land, set their foot in Bombay and were in the city for approximately two weeks. Thirumeni’s travelogue mentions that they arrived in Bombay during the Malayalam month of Kumbham (21) i.e. March 03, 1895. It is during this time that they happened to visit the St Peter’s Armenian Church at Colaba. Below are some extracts from his travelogue concerning their stay in Bombay.

Thirumeni was mesmerized with this city; he first explains the harbor scenery and the ships that adorn it. In Thirumeni’s words:

“We never saw such a big and beautiful city anywhere else during our journey. The Bombay harbor has prime importance in the whole India. As the city projects into the sea, it is surrounded on three sides by the sea. Ships can enter the bay, which is always very deep. The bay is divided into different segments, so that ships could be anchored in each of these segments, near the coast and safe from tempests raging in the sea. Each of these segments is protected by strong bunds. On both sides of these bunds there are roads wide enough for vehicles to ply. Ships can enter through rivers, and there are iron bridges across the rivers. These bridges could be lifted by machines when ships enter or leave the bay. Ships lie so close to the coast that it is possible to get into them with the help of a ladder. Sometimes one could get into the ships using just a plank……The sea is aglow with the lights of these ships during the night. When you look at the masts and chimneys of these ships from a distance, it may look like a forest with trees whose crests have been cut off!”

Mumbai is known as the land of skyscrapers in India and it was true 125 years back as well. Thirumeni’s keen eye for details is noted in the way he describes his ‘Bombay discoveries’. He says:

“The city is full of gigantic buildings. It is rather impossible to see single storeyed buildings except in villages outside the city.  Most of the houses have four to six floors. Some even have seven floors. Granite is used for the construction of buildings. The majority of the houses have verandahs for each floor. The painted railings for the verandahs are made of iron. Most buildings are terraced. People of our state who have not seen such big buildings and embellishments may look at them with wonder. On the top of each building there are architectural decorative works of pinnacles, railings, flowers or crosses and domes. It is an extremely beautiful sight to see buildings adjacent to each other and in rows. The houses have their names inscribed on them in golden letters for identification. These houses are distinguished by marble pillars, marble floors and costly household articles. Apollo Hotel, High Station (Victoria Terminus), General Hospital, Victoria garden etc. are amazing constructions. What was referred to as ‘garden’ is actually a museum which was a gift to the Queen made by David Sazoon. Though this zoo does not house as many birds and animals as in the zoo in Trivandrum, the building is certainly magnificent.

High Station (Victoria terminus) is the major railway station. The enormous building is famous for its architecture. A building in front of this can accommodate 16 trains at one time…nearby there is a silk factory and many cotton mills in the city.  There is no space here to give a detailed description of the shops in the city.
The roads are wide. There are numerous tram-carriages drawn by horses which provide cheap access to any place in the city, any time of the day…..there are footpaths and also granite pavements on both sides of the road.
Pipe water is made available in houses for drinking and bathing purposes. The lamps in important places are lit by electricity. There are number of telegraph offices and the telegraph facilities even in big shops. The inhabitants of this city are mostly Hindus, Muslims or Parsis. There are also Christians and Jews.”
Victoria Terminus now CST

And finally, Thirumeni speaks of the presence of clergy and church for a small Armenian Orthodox Christian community and like a loving shepherd wishes that a parish would have been developed for our community had there been a church and a priest. A quarter century later, through the Triune God’s immense grace and the mighty intercessions of the saintly fathers, the Bombay diocese of the Malankara Orthodox Church has numerous parishes to cater to the spiritual needs of the faithful.

“Though there are only five Armenian families, they have a priest and a church. The church is rich enough to give decent salary and allowances to the priest…if our community had a priest and a church here, it would have developed into a good parish. On Sunday we visited the Armenian Church- there was no Eucharistic service that day. Because the congregation was so small that they did not conduct service on every Sunday. The architecture of the church is same as that of a Syrian church.”

May the prayers of St Gregorios of Parumala and St Dionysius Vattasseril be a refuge for us.

In Christ,
Rincy John

(Ref: Oorsalem Yathra Vivarannam- Mar Gregorios Geevarghese, Sophia Books, Kottayam, pgs 13-17/ A Journey to Jerusalem- Pgs 44-48)

Saturday, March 7, 2020

Emperor Akbar/Mughal Empire’s Orthodox Christian connection.

Emperor Jehangir with a portrait of St Mary

The city of Agra is synonymous with the Taj Mahal, however unknown to many, there exists in this city (as also in some other Indian cities like Kolkata, Chennai, Gwalior, Hyderabad, Surat and Mumbai) the reminiscences of the Armenian Orthodox Christian community who made India their home.

India hasn’t been an alien nation for Armenians. It is believed that the Armenians first came to Indian in around 2000 BCE as faithful allies along with Semimaris, the warrior queen of Assyria, who had invaded India. They have also believed to come to India as auxillary elements in the army of Alexander of Macedonia. By 7th century their settlements appeared in Kerala and were known as ‘The Merchant Princes of India’.2

However, in the northern part of this country they were, as their chronicler Mehsorvb Jacob Seth calls, the birds of passage who came all the way from the land of Ararat of Biblical fame to purchase spices and fine muslins for which India was famous for. It was the Mughal emperor Akbar who invited them to settle in his province. The first notable Armenian there was a merchant called Hakob (Armenian-Jacob), originally from Aleppo. He settled in Agra upon the invitation of the Mogul emperor Akbar in 1560, serving in the Mogul court. Soon a small Armenian community was established in Agra, where it built a church in 1562.3

Akbar was aware that Armenians were a religious race of ancient Christians and would not settle in a place where they could not freely exercise the practice of their religious duties. (In the early 4th century, the Kingdom of Armenia became the first state to adopt Christianity as a state religion. Saint Gregory the Illuminator is the patron saint and first official head of the Armenian Apostolic Church).
The Armenian tradition very strongly propounds that Akbar had a Christian wife -an Armenian lady named Mariam (the Armenian nomenclature for Mary)- Mariam Zamani Begum. Henry George Keene (1781–1864), an East India Company employee and a historian mentions, also quoted in Seth’s works- “Besides the daughter of Amber, Akbar subsequently married at least two other foreign ladies, an Armenian and a princess of Marwar. Preserving unmolested in their palace their chapels and chaplains, these ladies would necessarily have their share in promoting the catholicity of Emperor’s mind and predisposing him to regard with favor Hindus and Christians” ( A Sketch of the history of Hindustan- From The First Muslim Conquest To The Fall Of The Mughol Empire, London, 1885, Pg-98).

However, the accepted viewpoint amongst Indian scholars is that Begum Maryam was the daughter of Raja Bihari Mal and mother of Jehangir (popularized in tradition as Jodha Bai).

Fr Hosten SJ’s findings, based on the assessment of two historical paintings assessed by (which was published in the Statesman, 14 Nov 1916), points the lady in the paintings to the Christian wife of Akbar. Mehsorvb Seth further comments that the lady in the paintings alongwith having Armenian features rather than European, wears a plain cross rather than a crucifix for a crucifix is never worn by an Armenian Christian. An Orthodox Armenian Christian wears a plain gold or silver cross.

Akbar’s court had several notable Armenian Christians- one of them Mirza Zul Qarnain who was an adopted son of Akbar. Zul Qarnain grew up in the palace and was one of the favorites of the Emperor. The records of the Jesuit fathers who visited Akbar’s court state that Akbar would be seen at the window with the young Zul Qarnain in his arms. The young boy had worn a cross around his neck which Akbar kissed and made the boy kiss too before the public gaze.

Akbar and his son Jehangir had great reverence for the Cross. Once the Jesuits solicited Emperor’s protection, to which he replied- “What would you have? See! I have more crosses on my palace than you have in your churches”.

Akbar’s son Jahangir once rebuked an Armenian for not wearing a cross on his head or on his breast.
Akbar’s adopted Christian son- Mirza Zul Qarnain grew up to be the Grandee (Amir) of the Mughal court through his merit. He was also a singer and poet of repute. Mirza Zul Qarnain was a philanthropist par excellence and he took great interest in the spiritual needs of the Christian subjects ensuring there is a presence of Armenian Orthodox priests (some of these priests are buried in the Agra Martyrose Chapel cemetery). So impressed were the Jesuit fathers from Goa who visited the Mughal court that they termed Zul Qarnain as the ‘pillar of Christianity in India’. Lady Juliana was another Armenian Christian and a doctor in the Mughal Court. 

About an hour’s drive from Agra is Fatehpur Sikri which was founded by Akbar in 1570 as a thanks offering for the birth of son (Salim, later Emperor Jehangir) obtained through the prayers of the famous Sufi saint-Shaikh Salim Chisti. Adjoining the Emperor’s palace is the residence of his christian Queen.

Amongst the majestic ruins of Fatehpur Sikri lies the Buland Darwaza or the High Gate, erected by Akbar in 1601 to commemorate his victory in the Deccan. It is the highest gateway in India and across the front of this gate is the following inscription- “Jesus, on whom be peace said: the world is a bridge, pass over it, but build not thereon. The world endureth but an hour, spend it in devotion”.
It is strange that Akbar, who was well acquainted with the teachings of Christ could have ascribed the above teaching to Jesus however the emperor seems to direct the readers to the thought-“Do not lay up for yourselves treasures on earth, where moth and rust destroy and where thieves break in and steal;  but lay up for yourselves treasures in heaven, where neither moth nor rust destroys and where thieves do not break in and steal”. St Matthew 6:19-20

It is interesting to note that one of the Queen’s relatives built the St Peter’s Armenian Church in Colaba, Mumbai which was visited by St Gregorios of Parumala and St Dionysius Vattasseril (the Fr Geevarghese Vattasseril Malpan) enroute to Holy Land pilgrimage. Owing to diminishing Armenians in Mumbai and that it shouldn’t be closed forever, this church has opened its doors for the faithful of the Malankara Orthodox Church to celebrate Divine Liturgy. One of the Armenian members Mrs. Zabel Joshi is the mother of the Hindi film actress Ms. Tulip Joshi.

Perhaps inter-religious marriages amongst the ruling class wasn’t a big deal and would have been a means of securing political mileage during those times. However, it is improbable to think that an Emperor of Islamic faith, though very benevolent to other religions, would show great interest in the learning of the Holy Scripture, reverence to the cross and have a child brought up in the palace nourished spiritually in the religion of his birth whom the Jesuits named as ‘father of Christianity in (northern) India’ had there not been an important woman behind the scenes- this woman being the Emperor’s Queen and foremost an Orthodox Christian woman. Though she is grossly under-researched by historians, her legacy lives on.

Oh, and by the way- Happy International Women’s Day in advance!

In Christ,

Rincy John

P.S: This article does not provide a comprehensive account of the major historical aspects of the Armenian christian community in India. You can read the books below for more information.

References: 
1) Mesrovb Jacob Seth, Armenians in India from the Earliest times to present day, Calcutta.
2) B. S. Ahloowalia, Invasion of the Genes Genetic Heritage of India, Eloquent Books, Pg 155, © 2009
3) Razmik Panossian, The Armenians- From Kings and Priests to Merchants and Commissars, C. Hurst & Co. (Publishers) Ltd,  Pg 80, 81, Copyright © by Razmik Panossian, 2006
4) Vasundara R-A Forgotten Church and Community: Meet Mumbai’s Last Surviving Armenian, Zabel Joshi, at https://www.idiva.com/career/advice/meet-mumbais-last-surviving-armenian-zabel-joshi-and-her-forgotten-church/15100671 (Accessed 06 March 2020)
5) Image courtesy: https://www.theheritagelab.in/christian-art-india/ 

Saturday, February 29, 2020

"Quo Vadis, Domine?"; "To be with the leper"- Reflections on the Gospel reading for the second Sunday of the Great Lent (Garbo Sunday).


Glory to the Triune God!

The Holy Gospel reading for the second Sunday of the Great Lent is from the Gospel of St Luke 5:12-16; 4:40-41. We will focus on the Gospel reading related to cleansing of leper.

“And it happened when He was in a certain city, that behold, a man who was full of leprosy saw Jesus; and he fell on his face and implored Him, saying, “Lord, if You are willing, You can make me clean.” Then He put out His hand and touched him, saying, “I am willing; be cleansed.” Immediately the leprosy left him. And He charged him to tell no one, “But go and show yourself to the priest, and make an offering for your cleansing, as a testimony to them, just as Moses commanded.”
However, the report went around concerning Him all the more; and great multitudes came together to hear, and to be healed by Him of their infirmities. So He Himself often withdrew into the wilderness and prayed.” (St Luke 5:12-16; NKJV).

The Jewish Rabbis saw leprosy as the external manifestation of an internal spiritual decay and hence focused on a spiritual care than a medical one. In the Hebrew society, leprosy was 'tzaraat' and it encompassed a wide variety of skin diseases also including the now known leprosy/Hansen's disease. One of the earliest mentions of such disease in the Holy Scripture is the affliction of Miriam, Moses's sister. She speaks ill of Moses when he married an Ethiopian wife. This slander and gossip made Miriam to be stricken with illness that leaves her skin flaky white. (The story is in Numbers 12). 

Will we be more careful with our words if we the result of gossip gave us skin deformity? 

In today's times, gossiping and spreading rumours about others is so much so much prevalent that they no longer attract our attention. Gossiping /speaking ill against a person or community leads to making the human (s)- the Lord' creation, to an object of hate, anger and possibly dehumanize them.

We don't like to accept that we indeed have flaws and that we need help. For us, misgivings only exist in others. It is interesting to note that the disease syphilis was called the "French disease" in Italy, Malta, Poland and Germany, and the "Italian disease" in France. The Dutch called it the "Spanish disease", the Russians called it the "Polish disease", and the Turks called it the "Christian disease". These "national" names served to act as the propaganda against the countries seen as their political/national opponents. As stated earlier, it helped to ‘dehumanize’ the ‘other’ people.

We saw it happening earlier and we see it happening now. Genocide and riots start with hate speech fed into the minds for days, months and years. In the time of this Lenten season let us with tears and prayers, seek our Lord's help as we hear racist hate speeches being orchestrated against the marginalized communities.

The prescribed ritual as seen in the book of Numbers and Leviticus is that the leprosy afflicted person was quarantined for some days. In Jewish concept such separation is seen as the time for repentance. After the prescribed period, "the priest shall go out of the camp, and the priest shall examine him" (Leviticus 14:3; NKJV).

As the 'chosen generation, a royal priesthood' (1 Peter 2:9), we are to go out and seek those who are sick (physically and spiritually) and bring them to the Church which the holy fathers have termed as a 'hospital'. In this Lenten season let us reflect how many times have we chosen to condemn a brother rather than help him to repent and come back!

Helping the physically and spiritually sick was a community task. “So Miriam was shut out of the camp seven days, and the people did not journey till Miriam was brought in again” (Numbers 12: 15; NKJV) The entire Israelite community waited for Miriam before they could journey again.

Our Orthodox faith teaches us that 'we may be lost alone but are saved together'!

"The Messiah at the Gates of Rome" is a traditional story in the Jewish tradition wherein Rabbi Joshua ben Levi has a vision in which he asks Prophet Elijah "When will the Messiah come?" to which the response is  "The Messiah is at the gates of Rome, sitting among the poor, the sick and wretched/lepers".

The Holy Tradition tells us that St Peter was crucified in Rome. A story goes that he was asked by fellow Christians to leave Rome for safety. While St Peter was escaping, he saw a vision of Christ heading towards Rome. St Peter exclaims "Where are you going Master" (Quo Vadis, Domine). Jesus responds that He is going to Rome to be crucified again since St Peter is running away from martyrdom. St Peter repents and goes back to Rome to fearlessly face the physical death.
Weren’t we all outraged when a wall was built to cover the slums when the POTUS visited our country? Isn’t that the way we are? We hate to admit as ours what is not pleasing to ours and others senses. 

And in such times when we see the Lord walking away from us, we call to him and ask- Quo Vadis, Domine? He will respond- "to the leper and outcasts because you aren’t allowing them in your midst"!

The leper in the Gospel reading might have been forgotten by the people (whereas the healing and caring for the sick was a community calling) and he implores the Lord to make him clean. The Lord wills that the leper is cleansed but also tells to show himself to the priest and make an offering for his cleansing. This passage also expounds on the importance of the sacrament of Holy Confession. If we sincerely repent over our wrongdoings, we are instructed by the Lord to share it with the confession father/priest for getting absolution.

Wishing all a blessed season of fasting and repentance.

In Christ,
Rincy John

Friday, February 14, 2020

A short biblical study on Onesiphorus- Sunday commemorating all the departed.


Verses for reflection: 2 Timothy 1:15-18 and 2 Timothy 4:19
Icon of Onesiphorus taken from oca.org
In the run-up to the great journey called the Great Lent we remember all the departed ones before the Sunday commemorating the miracle at the wedding at Cana. In relation to that let us study about a courageous man named Onesiphorus.

The name ‘Onesiphorus means "bringing advantage/beneficial". He is mentioned in the New Testament in 2 Timothy 1:16-18 and 2 Timothy 4:19. The passages are as below:

“This you know, that all those in Asia have turned away from me, among whom are Phygellus and Hermogenes. The Lord grant mercy to the household of Onesiphorus, for he often refreshed me, and was not ashamed of my chain; but when he arrived in Rome, he sought me out very zealously and found me. The Lord grant to him that he may find mercy from the Lord in that Day—and you know very well how many ways he ministered to me at Ephesus.” (2 Timothy 1:15-18; NKJV)

“Greet Prisca and Aquila, and the household of Onesiphorus” (2 Timothy 4:19; NKJV)

It is in the former verse that we get a small glimpse of this heroic figure named ‘Onesiphorus’. We understand from this passage that Onesiphorus was from Ephesus. He was not only a kind-hearted man but also a very courageous fellow. To be a helper to St Paul was easier said than done. St Paul says that Onesiphorus ‘was not ashamed of my chain’. St Paul was treated like a criminal in the Roman justice system. To be associated with a criminal was extremely dangerous. Perhaps that could be the reason that many deserted the apostle, fearing their own lives.

St Paul also says “he sought me out very zealously and found me”- this shows how brave Onesiphorus was. Imagine looking for and inquiring with people about a man who has been branded as a notorious criminal!  Onesiphorus own life would have been in grave danger, but instead of being ashamed and scared about association with St Paul, Onesiphorus’ servant heart reached out to the apostle whenever he needed it. His trusted friends had deserted him, and in these testing times, St Paul found a helping hand in Onesiphorus. St Paul vividly says ‘for he often refreshed me’. In the dark period of abandonment- Onesiphorus revived St Paul like a breath of fresh air. True to his name, Onesiphorus brought spiritual comfort to St Paul. It is worth thinking as how many of us would bring spiritual comfort in the lives of others?

There is another aspect worth noting in these two verses.

1) Onesiphorus’s household/family is mentioned twice by St Paul in the second letter to Timothy. In the second instance, St Paul doesn’t ask Timothy to greet Onesiphorus. Instead, he says: “Greet Prisca and Aquila and the family of Onesiphorus” (2 Timothy 4:19).

2) Secondly, all of Onesiphorus’ earthly actions are spoken of in the past tense. On a quick note it may seem that the apostle is narrating Onesiphorus’s service when St Paul needed it, but St Paul further adds and praises Onesiphorus for “the services he rendered in Ephesus,” without referring to any services that he is currently rendering.

3) Thirdly, note the difference in St Paul’s prayers for Onesiphorus and his household.
  • For  Onesiphorus’ household: “The Lord grant mercy to the household of Onesiphorus” (verse 16).
  • For Onesiphorus-  “The Lord grant to him that he may find mercy from the Lord in that Day” (verse 18)

St Paul prays about Onesiphorus’s family in the present tense, whereas only for Onesiphorus, it’s something to do with future.

All these points demonstrate that Onesiphorus has departed from the earthly life while this letter was written. If not, why isnt St Paul asking Timothy to greet Onesiphorus; instead he asks to greet his family. If not, why are only past earthly actions of Onesiphorus spoken of and there is no mention of his current ministry while St Paul is writing the letter. If not, why is the prayer for Onesiphorus and his household different?

“The Lord grant to him that he may find mercy from the Lord in that Day”.

St Paul prayed that the Lord has mercy on Onesiphorus’ soul on His Second Coming. Praying for the departed ones is entrenched in the Holy Scripture- it’s a biblical reality.

‘Onesiphorus’ name meant "bringing advantage/beneficial". In his earthly life, Onesiphorus was beneficial to St Paul in joy and in chains. Truly, St Paul’s prayer for his beloved departed friend would have indeed been a source of comfort for Onesiphorus.

May the intercessions and prayers of the holy apostles, saints and martyrs be a source of comfort for us and our departed ones.

Lord have mercy!

In Christ,
Rincy John

Thursday, November 21, 2019

21 November- Feast commemorating the entry of Saint Mary the Theotokos into the Jerusalem Temple.

Icon showing Joachim and Anna submitting
 the baby Mary to the Temple.
On the top left we see the angel giving food to St Mary.

Today the liturgical calendar of the Indian Orthodox Church commemorates yet another feast relating to St Mary - the feast of the entrance of the Theotokos into the Temple of Jerusalem.

The pious parents of St Mary-the Theotokos, Joachim and Anna were childless for a long time and hence had to face the shame and humiliation of the society. With tears and prayers both Joachim and Anna sought a child; Anna made a vow to dedicate the child to God. When St Mary was two years old, Joachim proposed that they take the child to the Temple to dedicate her to God, but Anna suggested that they wait one more year so that the child may not seek the father or the mother.

When the child was three years old, Joachim invited Hebrew females to accompany Mary while they take her to the Temple. As a child eager to go to her Father’s home, the young child joyfully climbed the steps of the Temple. The parents marveled, and praised the Lord, that the child had not turned back nor was she weeping for her parents.

And the priest received her, and kissed her, and blessed her, saying: “The Lord has magnified your name in all generations. In you, on the last of the days, the Lord will manifest His redemption to the sons of Israel”.
And he set her down upon the third step of the altar, and the Lord God sent grace upon her; and she danced with her feet, and all the house of Israel loved her!
St Mary-Theotokos was in the Temple of the Lord as if she were a dove that dwelt there, and she received food from the hand of an angel. She was there in the temple until her betrothal to St Joseph the Righteous.

By the intercessions of St Mary-the Theotokos and St Joseph the Righteous, may the Lord have mercy upon us.

In Christ,
Rincy John

(Ref: The Protoevangelium of James; Ante-Nicene Fathers, Volume VIII, edited by Roberts and Donaldson)


Friday, November 15, 2019

16 November- National Press Day/ Alvares Thirumeni as the patron saint of the journalists.

Glory to the Triune God.


His Grace Alvares Mar Julius (of blessed memory)
November 16th is celebrated as National Press Day in India to commemorate the establishment of the Press Council of India. This day personifies a responsible and free press in the country even though we live in an age where the fourth pillar of the democracy is seen with a questioning eye as a major chunk seems to be the mouthpiece of the ruling establishments rather than being the voice of the people.

Roughly 150 years back there lived a saintly man who used the medium of press to fearlessly expose the ills and shortcomings of the authorities- whether it was government, ecclesiastical and spoke for the rights of the common man. The Orthodox bishop- His Grace Alvares Mar Julius (of blessed memory), who also donned the garb of a journalist along with his episcopal duties and whose unorthodox, non-conformist stance on Roman church and Portuguese rule earned him the ire of the authorities.

Bishop Alvares was born and raised in Goa- a state we now associate with beaches and vacations only. Goa hardly comes to our mind when we are asked about independence movement against colonial powers. This tiny state of Goa has produced over 300 journals in a span of 140 years with a focus against colonial occupation and was home to several notable freedom fighters.
Alvares Thirumeni’s stint with journalism started somewhere in 1876/77 when he took over the editorship of ‘A Cruz’, a weekly started by Fr MA de Carvalho, as Fr Carvalho was struck with pulmonary tuberculosis. [Alvares Thirumeni is also credited with publishing a booklet on the treatment of Cholera].

Not the one to mince words Fr Alvares wasn’t afraid to call a spade a spade. For e.g. writing scathing pieces against the excesses of the Portuguese rule, he said thus about the arrival of Vasco da Gama and the conquest of Goa by Albuquerque;

“The banditry and piracy through which the rich city of Goa—the celebrated empire of the Orient—was taken, has no justification in the laws of divinity or of humankind. All manner of oratory and poetry are unable to render holy, just, and right, what was in fact the work of piracy”.

Speaking against the brutal plunder and oppression of the Portuguese, Fr Alvares said that though India was invaded many times, all forces apart from Portuguese were naturalized. Such statements were considered blasphemous in those times!

Fr Alvares critiques didn’t go well with the Portuguese ecclesiastical hierarchy and he had to soon bear the brunt when the new Archbishop Dom Antonio Sebastio Valente, known for authoritarian mindset, through a pastoral decree banned A Cruz. Fr Alvares appealed to the Crown and though he got a favorable ruling from the Goa High Court, A Cruz had lost its readers because of Archbishop’s orders which forced Fr Alvares to start another weekly- A Verdade wherein he carried his fight on what he felt was the truth (Verdade means truth).

Fr Alvares is also credited to bring out the first journal to experiment in English (in Goa)- ‘The Times of Goa. For a renaissance of the Goan political environment, he suggested to have a ‘journal in English-which is today almost a universal language’.

Fr Alvares was also a vocal opponent of the economic policies of the Portuguese. Citing the miserable economic situation of the common man, he declared that ‘a middle class Goan with land had about 650 rupees in hand annually, after paying all dues and taxes. This was scarcely sufficient to meet the needs of a family in 1877’ and that the Portuguese economic policies had strengthened Portuguese as well as British markets. In 1895 he tried to initiate a campaign to boycott all Portuguese imports.

In Alvares Thirumeni’s periodical 'O Brado Indiano' one finds the beginning of genuine Indian protest as indicated in its title. In one of its editorials in 1895, it cried to drive the beggars (the Portuguese) out from the country and proclaimed independence.

Through his newspaper Alvares Thirumeni conducted a determined campaign against the corrupt and negligent officials of the Portuguese administration of Goa. It was only a matter of time that Alvares Thirumeni’s periodicals and newspapers would become subject to state surveillance.

In the July 1985 issue of O Brado Indiano, the newspaper carried an article which invited its readers to identify the corrupt government official with the help of riddles. The administrator of Ilhas- Manuel Gomes DaCosta, thoroughly offended by the article, slapped sedition charges on Alvares Thirumeni. In the evening of 19th August, 6 policemen in disguise stopped Alvares Thirumeni on his way back home, took advantage of his poor health, forced him into their car and took him to the police station. He was kept in a filthy, dark cell without ventilation which was 3 metres long and 1.5 metres wide. After questioning Thirumeni, the judge soon released him as he noted that the police hadn’t adopted the correct procedure. Thirumeni was arrested following evening on the charges of apostasy and to humiliate him, Thirumeni was stripped of his episcopal attire and paraded to the court in his undergarments.

In the month of September, the same year, the sepoys of the Portuguese Indian army staged a mutiny protesting the orders of moving to Mozambique. Gomes da Costa had blamed prominent Goans like the Viscount of Bardez (the mayor)- Mr. Ignacio Caetano de Carvalho and Alvares Thirumeni for instigating the sepoys and the general public to unite and fight for the cause of “India for the Indians.”! Mr. Carvalho was a Goan employed in the judiciary and owned and edited a number of newspapers in Goa (all of these were anti-establishment papers). Mr. Carvalho published a pamphlet in Bombay in defense of himself and Alvares Thirumeni stating that the rebellion had nothing to do with newspapers but had been prompted by bad governance and callousness.

The Viscount of Bardez lamented thus when writing about the unlawful sedition charges against Alvares Thirumeni-

“In all governments that are not absolutely corrupt, the functionaries are obliged when questioned, to justify themselves through legal organs and through the press. In Goa, things proceeded directly to the contrary…The attitude of the administration in India will pull back Indian society by more than 400 years”. Seems so true in today’s times!

This article just gives glimpses of Alvares Thirumeni’s stint with journalism in Goa and is not an exhaustive coverage of his works. He lived in an era with press restrictions and where harassment was a norm when one wrote against the authorities or questioned them. Even when faced with great tribulations there are fearless men and women who like Alvares Thirumeni bring truth to the public and fight on their behalf. May our Lord bless them!

May the memory of Alvares Thirumeni be eternal and may his prayers and intercession be a source of strength and refuge to the ‘truth-informers’ of our country!

In Christ,
Rincy John

****************************************
Some details about Alvares Thirumeni's publications/periodicals/newspapers in Goa are as follows:

1) Name: O Progresso de Goa
Periodicity: Weekly
Duration: Began and ended in 1883

2) O Brado Indian(The Indian Cry)       
Periodicity: Weekly
Duration: Dec. 15, 1894 to Oct. 12, 1895 (10 months)

3) Name: A Cruz
Periodicity: Fortnightly
Duration: July15, 1876 to July18, 1882.
Editors-Fr. Manuel Agostinho de Carvalho and Fr. Antonio F. X. Alvares

4) Verdade (A)
Periodicity: Weekly Periodical
Duration: July 16, 1882 to Dec. 31, 1885.

5) The Times of Goa
Periodicity: Weekly
Duration: Sep. 21, 1885 to 1889
************************************************
References: 
  1. Rochelle Pinto, BETWEEN EMPIRES: Print and Politics in Goa, Oxford University Press, New Delhi © Oxford University Press 2007, Pgs 37, 40, 49, 146-9)
  2. Rochelle Pinto. (2005). A Time to Publish: Pamphlets and Politics in Colonial Goa. Economic and Political Weekly, 40(9), 877-885. Retrieved from www.jstor.org/stable/4416278
  3. Carmo Azevedo; ‘Public Life in Goa (1867-1887)’; Patriot and Saint- The Life Story of Bishop Mar Julius –I Page 19-23, Panjim 1988
  4. Rekha Mishra, History Of The Press In Goa, Doctoral Thesis, Goa University, 2004- http://irgu.unigoa.ac.in/drs/handle/unigoa/3905; Accessed on 03 September 2019.
  5. Uma Página Negra dos Annaes da História Colonial Portugueza, , Nova Goa, 1895, Pg 118- 120 (translation from Portuguese to English were done using google translate).
  6. Pratima Kamat, Mutiny in the Portuguese Indian Army, Pg 92, Link here.
  7. Pratima Kamat, H.G. MAR JULIUS ALVARES METROPOLITAN OF CEYLON, GOA AND INDIA: AN APOSTLE OF ‘FAITH, HOPE AND CHARITY’, Link here.
  8. Henry Scholberg, Journalism in Portuguese India 1821-1961, Link here.



Monday, October 21, 2019

Journey with the Holy Bible (Posting 1)

Journey with the Holy Bible.
Verse for reflection: St Mathew 1:1
When the new year arrives most of us do make resolutions-e.g. lose weight, spend less, learn some new skills etc. In few days time we will welcome the liturgical new year ‘Kudosh Etho’ – the theme of Kudosh Etho Sunday being sanctification. Let us try as we usher in the spiritual new year to read the Holy Bible a bit more habitually- may the Lord illumine our hearts and may the prayers of the saints and holy fathers and mothers help us in this journey.

P.S. The postings will be on Monday, Wednesday and Friday.

Let us begin where the New Testament starts- the Gospel of St Mathew. The gospel begin begins with the genealogy of our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ. The story starts with how the Lord became one among us.
We will ponder over two questions-

1) What was the reason for this Gospel to begin with the genealogy and

2) why did the story of salvation have our Lord become human?
Regarding the first question, St. Matthew was writing to the Jews about our Lord Jesus Christ being the Messiah King. The Israelites were waiting for the Messiah who would be a descendant of King David to redeem them (hence for the Jews the genealogy held great importance). Several Old Testament prophecies attests to this:
The Lord spoke to king David through Nathan the prophet-
"And your house and your kingdom shall be established forever before you. Your throne shall be established forever.” (2 Samuel 7: 16; NKJV).

““Behold, the days are coming,” says the Lord, “That I will raise to David a Branch of righteousness; A King shall reign and prosper, And execute judgment and righteousness in the earth.
In His days Judah will be saved, And Israel will dwell safely; Now this is His name by which He will be called:THE LORD OUR RIGHTEOUSNESS.”(Jeremiah 23: 5-6 and Jeremiah 33:15; NKJV).
We also see a similar prophecy in the book of Isaiah –
“And in that day there shall be a Root of Jesse, Who shall stand as a banner to the people; For the Gentiles shall seek Him, And His resting place shall be glorious.”(Isaiah 11:10; NKJV).
St John Chrysostom says that though the genealogy begins with Abraham in verse 2 onwards, the Gospel verse addresses Jesus Christ as Son of David first. It is because the memory of King David was recent in the minds of the people as compared to Abraham.
Another reason to mention the lineage is to answer heretic groups like the agnostics who hated the physical body and thus denied the incarnation of the Lord claiming Christ to be a mirage or shadow. Though this movement was prominent in second century, its roots began at a very early age. So, mentioning the lineage is an assurance of the truthfulness of God’s incarnation. (Ref: Fr Tadros Malaty, commentary on Gospel of Matthew).

In Christ,
Rincy John